From Asceticism to the Flower Sermon: The Generative Drive Is the World
Part One · The Generative Drive Impels the World
By Shaolong (绍隆) · Draft 6 · 13 October 2026
Abstract
This article argues for a strong monistic thesis: the world is the self-differentiating modes of the generative drive (性力, xingli) toward difference and otherness. The argument proceeds on three levels. At the level of natural history (the peacock's tail, the orientation of the sunflower head, canine olfaction, the pappus of the dandelion, habituation in the sensitive plant), the structure of generation toward difference and the other runs through forms of life that do not think. At the level of human behavior (creativity, compassion, post-consummatory satiety), phenomena that are named separately share a reward structure and a direction of generation. At the phenomenological level (a contrast between narrow-sense and broad-sense sexual experience), the two differ not in whether pleasure is present but in informational bandwidth and in the breadth of what is united with. The three levels converge in support of P3: the generative drive, that is, the self-transcending drive toward difference and the other, cannot be replaced by any other principle within the domain of life. This article supplies the empirical correlates for the a priori argument of Part Two. Keywords: generative drive (性力); monism; generative becoming; natural history; reward system
1. Introduction: A Widely Misunderstood Phenomenon
1.1 The Thesis and the Strength of "Is" (即) This article argues that the world is (即) the self-differentiating modes of the generative drive. The "is" admits four degrees of strength. The weakest: the generative drive is one important factor in the world (pluralism). Next: the generative drive is the basic drive of the domain of life, while the physical domain has principles of its own (dualism). Stronger: the generative drive and the world are inseparable in terms of genesis, but remain distinguishable in concept (weak monism). Strongest: the generative drive just is the world in its generation and self-differentiation, as heat just is the random motion of molecules (strong monism). This article adopts the strongest reading. It means: not "the world is driven by the generative drive" (driving presupposes two things), but "the generation of the world is the self-differentiation of the generative drive" (there is only one thing).
1.2 Methodological Statement This is Part One; it supplies empirical correlates, and the metaphysical argument is reserved for Part Two. The task of Part One is to show that, from plants to humans and from mating to creation, phenomena that are named separately are isomorphic in their generative structure, and that this structure cannot be absorbed either by the more general notion of "energy" or by the more specific notion of "reproduction." The use of empirical research here observes three disciplines: correlational findings are not written up as causal; the limits of small samples and cross-sectional designs are noted where the studies are cited; and every reading supplied by the author is marked as "interpretation." This article does not rely on any physiological mechanism to bear argumentative weight. The mechanism by which continence operates, and the simultaneity of "luminous awareness" (觉知), are treated in Part Two on the basis of classical teachings.
1.3 Plan of the Article Section 2 defines the concepts. Section 3 gives the empirical form of the main argument. Section 4 offers evidence from natural history. Section 5 offers evidence from the level of human behavior. Section 6 gives a phenomenological contrast between narrow- sense and broad-sense sexual experience. Section 7 addresses the strongest objections. Section 8 concludes and points to Part Two.
2. Conceptual Definitions
2.1 Four Senses of the Generative Drive In everyday language the term 性力 (xingli, literally "sex-force"), rendered here as "generative drive," is very easily read too narrowly. This article first distinguishes four senses. First, sexual desire: the impulse toward reproductive union. Second, sexual capacity: function at the level of reproductive physiology. Third, the generative drive in the broad sense: psychological drive and vital energy. Fourth, bodily-energetic experience: the heat, tingling, and lightness and ease (轻安, qing'an) reported in contemplative practice. The four are manifestations of one generative drive at different levels; they are related, not identical. Unless otherwise noted, the "generative drive" of this article is taken in the third sense, and is defined in terms of genesis as: life's self-transcending impulse of generation toward difference and the other. This definition differs from Freud's libido in three respects. First, Freud ties libido to the individual psyche, whereas this article establishes the generative drive as an ontological principle. Second, Freud's "sublimation" presupposes that reproduction is the original aim and creation a substitute; this article does not accept that hierarchy: mating and creation are manifestations of the same drive at different levels, not an original and its replacement. Third, Freud never pushed libido to monism: his instinct dualism (the life instinct, Eros, against the death instinct, Thanatos) runs in the direction opposite to the strong monism defended here. Nor is the generative drive of this article the same as Bergson's élan vital, Nietzsche's will to power, or Deleuze's desire. Bergson's impulse is an anti-entropic organizing force, whereas the generative drive is generation toward the other; Nietzsche's will to power may be an expansion of the self, whereas the generative drive necessarily moves toward difference; Deleuze's desire is a productive flow, whereas the generative drive places more weight on the direction of self-transcendence. The four can be put in dialogue, but they are not equivalent.
2.2 Narrow-Sense and Broad-Sense Sexual Experience Narrow-sense sexual experience is the pleasure of union in the reproductive system, usually with a particular other person. Broad-sense sexual experience is the ultimate delight an individual life feels when it breaks through its own boundary and enters deep union with what lies outside (nature, other people, ideas, art). The two differ not in whether pleasure is present but in the following dimensions:
Dimension Narrow-sense Broad-sense
Trigger Particular physiological organs and psychological Any act that breaks the boundary of the self and establishes deep stimuli connection
Object of union One's own discharge, or a particular other person The self with nature, others, ideas, art
Temporal character A brief burst, followed by emptiness Lasting fullness, in which one can dwell constantly
Insight gained Little; ends in the senses Much; often accompanied by a new understanding of the world
Informational Narrowed to a local organ Open to the whole intentional field bandwidth
This contrast makes no value judgment and serves only to locate structure: the narrow sense is the most manifest and most basic special case of the broad sense on the material level, not the whole of it.
3. The Empirical Form of the Main Argument This section gives the logical skeleton of the argument; the next two sections supply the empirical material.
3.1 Four Propositions P1 The world is becoming, not being. Any static identity is an abstract slice; concrete reality can only be self-differentiating becoming.
P2 The direction of becoming is toward difference and the other. Isolated self-repetition is not becoming; only self- transcendence toward the other constitutes real differentiation. P3 The generative drive, that is, the self-transcending drive toward difference and the other, is the name under which this self- differentiating becoming shows itself in life, and within the domain of life it cannot be replaced by any other principle (will to power, vital impulse, conservation of energy). C Therefore, the world is the self-differentiating modes of the generative drive. P1 is the phenomenological starting point. P2 is an a priori argument, whose full defense belongs to Part Two. P3 is the work of this part. It must show that, from plants to humans and from mating to creation, phenomena named separately are in their generative structure one and the same, and that this structure cannot be absorbed either by the more general "energy" or by the more specific "reproduction." The former is too empty: it cannot explain why generation always moves toward the other. The latter is too narrow: it cannot explain why creation and compassion share a reward structure with mating. The next three sections provide empirical correlates for P3 at the level of natural history, the level of human behavior, and the phenomenological level, in turn.
3.2 Argumentative Strategy This article does not claim that "everything is sex." It claims that when we look at the world in terms of genesis, phenomena named separately (mating, creation, compassion, aesthetic response) share one generative structure: self-transcendence toward difference and the other. In everyday language this structure is most often named by "sex" at its most manifest level (reproductive union), but the structure itself is not confined to reproduction. What this article does is extend the structure from the reproductive domain to the whole domain of life, and argue that the generative drive, so extended, cannot be replaced by other concepts.
4. Natural History: Movement Toward the Other in Life Without Thought The examples from natural history fall into two classes. Class B comprises cases in which generation is directed straight at the other (the peacock, the sunflower, canine olfaction) and which bear the weight of P3. Class A comprises cases of response without representation (the dandelion, the sensitive plant), which only show that this orientation does not need thought as a medium and do not bear the weight of P3 on their own.
4.1 Darwin's Peacock Question On 3 April 1860 Darwin wrote to his friend Asa Gray: "The sight of a feather in a peacock's tail, whenever I gaze at it, makes me sick!"1 Why sick? Because natural selection could not explain it: the tail is burdensome, costly in energy, and attracts enemies, with no benefit to survival. For this reason Darwin set up the theory of "sexual selection," set out in The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex (1871). This article presses one step further: what, exactly, does sexual selection select? The answer: the generative drive, the manifestation of life's primal force. The peacock's tail is one display of the generative drive over the long course of evolution: burdensome yet beautiful, beautiful and therefore chosen, chosen and therefore passed on. Aesthetic response precedes function; the generative drive precedes survival. This is the present article's own advance, and it must be distinguished from Darwin's meaning: Darwin set sexual selection beside natural selection and never claimed that all evolution is driven by the generative drive. This article goes one step further: what sexual selection discloses is the general driving force of evolution, the generative drive. The competition for survival under natural selection may be seen as the unfolding of the generative drive in the domain of survival; the competition for mates under sexual selection is its unfolding in the domain of reproduction. Two domains, one force. (Interpretation: this is a theoretical reconstruction by this article, not Darwin's own claim.)
4.2 Canine Olfaction: The Directed Irrigation of a Sensory Channel by the Generative Drive The most eloquent counter-case in nature comes from a dog's nose. Humans have about 6 million olfactory receptors, and the olfactory cortex occupies less than 1% of the cerebral cortex; the domestic dog has about 300 million olfactory receptors, and the proportion of its cortex given to olfaction is 40 times the human proportion. In terms of hardware invested in receiving "information about the world," the dog overwhelmingly surpasses the human along the olfactory dimension. How did this superiority come about? The answer is hidden in the logic of reproduction. The social life and reproduction of canids run almost entirely on scent. Specific volatile compounds secreted by a bitch in estrus
can be detected by males several kilometers away; by sniffing urine marks, dogs can read the other's sex, estrous state, health, and even level of emotional stress. More finely, mammals identify the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genotype of a potential partner by scent: the greater the MHC difference, the greater the immune diversity of the offspring. Olfaction has thus been, over hundreds of millions of years of evolution, a biological instrument for assessing "genetic compatibility."2 In other words, the reproductive choices of dogs take scent as the central criterion; in this species the generative drive has put the largest share of its resources into the olfactory channel. The ethologist Alexandra Horowitz points out in Inside of a Dog (2009) that for a dog, scent has a temporal dimension: it can smell "who passed by an hour ago" and "whether that one was eating or running at the time."3 This is not a simple sensory stimulus but a way of accessing the world that encodes the present together with its temporal history. It is the sustained pressure of sexual selection that has honed this mode of access to a precision beyond the limits of human perception. This article defines this as the directed irrigation of a sensory channel by the generative drive (interpretation): when the reproductive circuit of a species depends deeply on a given sensory channel, the generative drive keeps investing along that channel and, on an evolutionary scale of hundreds of millions of years, hones it to the highest acuity. The dog never resolved to train its nose; the generative drive worked on it, and a response arose. It should be noted that the evolution of canine olfaction has also been shaped by selective pressures such as hunting and group living; only its reproductive aspect is taken here as an interpretive narrative, and this article does not claim it is the sole cause. The self-conscious form of this logic appears in contemplative traditions; its mechanism is treated in Part Two and is not developed here. (Note: the MHC and scent-recognition mechanism is supported by experimental studies in rodents and humans; "the generative drive irrigates a sensory channel" is the author's interpretive narrative based on evolutionary logic, not a direct experimental conclusion.)
4.3 The Sunflower: Rhythmic Generation Toward the Pollinator (Class B) Young sunflower plants (Helianthus annuus) turn with the sun from east to west during the day and turn back to the east at night. This rhythm persists under constant light, which shows that it is driven by an internal circadian rhythm, and the plant can turn before dawn, so that it is not merely passively following the light. Once the plant matures, the stem stops growing and the flower head is fixed facing east.4 Subsequent field and controlled experiments, which artificially altered the orientation and temperature of the flower heads, found that east-facing heads, compared with those set to face west, showed earlier style elongation and pollen presentation and earlier and more frequent pollinator visits; the authors relate this to the daily rhythm of floral temperature and to the plant's reproductive fitness.5 Here the "other" is the pollinator, and structure is directly tied to reproductive success. This is another example, after the peacock, of "toward the other" in a life without a nervous system. Two points must be kept apart. First, the sun-tracking of young plants chiefly concerns growth and photosynthesis (Atamian et al. report that it increases vegetative biomass) and belongs to Class A, response without a brain; only the fixed orientation of the mature flower head is tied to pollinators, and only that is taken here as Class B evidence. Second, sexual selection in plants is still disputed in the literature, so the empirical level is always described as "pollinator-mediated selection": photoreception, rhythmic response, pollinator-mediated selection, and sedimentation across generations. The drivers of evolution are variation and selection, not pleasure; this article does not claim that plants have pleasure or consciousness. (Interpretation: pollinator-mediated selection is, in this article's view, the unfolding of the generative drive in the plant domain: the plant's "courtship" is conducted through a third party. The structure that has settled out is a record, in form, of the long encounter between flower and environment, which this article calls "knowing" in a weak sense: it refers only to a structure's response to, anticipation of, and sedimentation of its environment, and is not equivalent to the "luminous awareness" discussed in Part Two; its ultimate nature is left to Part Two.)
4.4 Dandelion and Sensitive Plant: Knowing Without Representation (Class A) The pappus of the dandelion (Taraxacum spp.) seed is a marvel of efficiency in natural fluid dynamics. Cummins et al. (2018) studied its flight in a wind tunnel and found that the pappus forms a separated vortex ring in flight, a stable fluid structure that gives this extremely light structure a high drag, so that the seed sinks slowly and is carried far on the wind.6 The question is: the dandelion has no eyes, no nervous system, no known sense organ; how does it "know" that there is wind, and how does it "know" to build a structure so well coupled to the fluid dynamics of wind? The answer of this article: it does not need to "know" the wind exists; it only needs to be selected in its long encounter with the wind. Individuals whose pappus structure happened to couple well with the wind field dispersed farther and left more offspring. The
dandelion's "knowing" is not representational cognition but the sedimentation, in form, of long interaction between structure and environment. This is a weak sense of "knowing" (interpretation): independent of representation and without thought, yet showing in behavior a precise response to the environment. The sensitive plant (Mimosa pudica) folds its leaves when touched. But Gagliano et al. (2014) report that if it is repeatedly stimulated in a harmless way (for example, dropped from a fixed height), it "learns" not to fold; this habituation can last at least a month and persist even after the environment changes.7 It should be noted that the conclusions of such plant habituation experiments are still being tested, and this article takes them only as a structural suggestion. This is memory, and the sensitive plant has no nervous system. What it "remembers" is not a representation but an imprint of the stimulus pattern on its physiological state. This article places it in the same class as the dandelion: different forms of knowing without representation, the dandelion's being a structural sedimentation across generations and the sensitive plant's a physiological memory within a single individual. Neither depends on thought or representation, yet both show learning and response in relation to the environment. (Note: Cummins et al.'s fluid-dynamic work is experimental fact; "knowing in a weak sense" is this article's phenomenological interpretation and does not claim that plants have consciousness.)
4.5 Summary: A Structure of Movement Toward the Other The three Class B cases (the peacock's tail, the orientation of the sunflower head, canine olfaction) involve generation aimed directly at the other: mate, pollinator, scent signal. The two Class A cases (the dandelion's pappus, habituation in the sensitive plant) show response and sedimentation without representation. Taken together they point to one thing: generation toward the other does not need thought as an intermediary. All these structures result from being selected and carved by the environment in the encounter between life and what is around it. This is not teleology. No external purpose prescribed in advance that "the peacock should grow a beautiful tail"; only under the selective pressure of the peahen's preference was the tail pushed in that direction. Purpose is not at the beginning; it is generated in the process. Nor is it mechanism. Mechanism says: the environment exerts causal force and life responds passively. But "being selected" is not "being pushed": the variation in each generation is random, and selection only retains the variants that happen to couple with the environment. Life is not determined by the environment; it differentiates itself in its encounter with the environment. This article calls it self-transcending generation toward the other: life is not closed self-repetition but, in its encounters with others (mate, pollinator, wind, light, chemical signal), keeps breaking old equilibria and generating new structures. This directionality is precisely the manifestation, at the level of natural history, of what this article defines as the "generative drive." Question left open, no. 1: The coupling between these structures and their environments is so precise; does the coupling itself count as a kind of "knowing"? If so, what is it? Part One can only describe to this point; it cannot answer.
5. Human Behavior: A Shared Reward Structure
5.1 The Neural Association Between Creativity and Sex The association between human creative behavior and sex has preliminary support in neuroscience, but its strength must be stated clearly. Correlational evidence. Griskevicius, Cialdini, and Kenrick (2006) found, in a series of experiments, that once a mating motive was activated, men's performance on creative tasks improved significantly.8 The survey by Nettle and Clegg (2006) showed that poets and artists have more sexual partners than average, and that this correlates positively with their measures of creativity.9 The common finding of these studies is a positive correlation between sexual motivation and creativity. But three limitations must be noted. First, correlation is not causation: it may be that creativity itself attracts more partners, or that both are driven by a third variable (such as openness to experience). Second, these studies do not support the claim that "one must be continent in order to create"; on the contrary, they show that the activation of sexual motivation (not its suppression) rises together with creativity. Third, the samples are mostly university students or artists, and generalizing to the general population requires caution. The use made of these studies here is limited to the following structural claim: sex and creativity share, to some degree, a motivational system, and are not two mutually independent domains. This is compatible with the thesis of this article: if the generative drive is generation toward the other, then it appears as mating in the reproductive domain and as creation in the cognitive domain, and the two share a direction rather than overlapping by chance.
5.2 The Neural Basis of Compassion Compassion is, phenomenologically, empathic resonance with another's suffering together with the will to relieve it. If the thesis of this article holds (the generative drive is generation toward the other), then compassion should share certain neural structures with the generative drive. Preliminary evidence. Klimecki et al. (2014) compared the effects of compassion training and empathy training on the brain. After compassion training, subjects watching others suffer showed marked activation of the ventral striatum and the orbitofrontal cortex, the core regions of the reward network, whereas empathy training alone activated regions associated with negative emotion (anterior insula, anterior cingulate).10 This indicates that compassion is not only "feeling the suffering of others" (which would activate the pain circuit) but "feeling the will and the possibility of relieving others' suffering" (which activates the reward circuit). The neural signature of compassion partly overlaps with that of other rewarding experiences such as sex, eating, and aesthetic response. Structural implication. This article does not claim that compassion "is" the generative drive, but that compassion and sex share a reward structure at the neural level because both, in terms of genesis, are generation toward the other: sex toward a mate or offspring, compassion toward all who suffer. Shared reward circuitry is not a coincidence but the unfolding of the same generative direction on different objects. (Note: the sample of Klimecki et al. is small and the conclusions are preliminary; this article takes only their structural compatibility and makes no neurodeterministic claim. It should further be noted that activation of the reward network is not specific to sex or compassion, but occurs also with eating, social approval, and so on; only compatibility is taken here, and no specific identity is inferred from it.)
5.3 The Evolutionary Link Between Aesthetic Response and Sex Aesthetic preference is bound up with sexual selection in evolution. Miller (2000), in The Mating Mind, argues systematically that human aesthetic capacities in art, music, and humor are very likely products of sexual selection: they are "honest signals" displaying cognitive resources and genetic quality.11 The peacock's tail is the most direct example (see 4.1): beauty itself becomes the criterion of choice, beautiful individuals leave more offspring, and beauty is thus pushed to an extreme by sexual selection. Human aesthetic preferences (for symmetry, complexity, novelty) have in many studies been shown to be related to mate choice.12 The thesis of this article: aesthetic response is not a "by-product" of sex but the direct unfolding of the generative drive in the cognitive domain. When humans experience beauty in a sunset, in music, or in a mathematical theorem, the structure of that thrill and delight shares one generative direction with sexual climax, the satisfaction of compassion, and the ecstasy of creation: to break the boundary of the self and enter deep union with the other (whether another person, a melody, or an abstract truth).
5.4 Three Layers of Evidence for Post-Consummatory Satiety If narrow-sense sexual experience is the narrowed manifestation of the broad generative drive in the reproductive domain, then the peak of reproductive union should be followed by a state of satiety: not merely the physiological refractory period, but a temporary satisfaction at the level of motivation. This prediction can be supported on three levels. The neural circuit. Zhou et al. (2023) found in mice that ejaculation selectively activates neurons expressing estrogen receptor 2 in the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BNST Esr2), putting them into a hyperexcited state lasting several days; this state encodes sexual satiety and lowers mating motivation. Experimentally inhibiting these neurons restores mating motivation, and activating them makes unsated animals lose their willingness to mate.13 This is the most direct study of the neural basis of sexual satiety to date. Two points must be noted: first, this is a mouse model and can be applied to humans only as a structural analogy; second, what the study measured was approach toward the opposite sex and mating motivation, not general curiosity or cognitive ability. The endocrine level. Brody and Krüger (2006) found that plasma prolactin rises after orgasm, and that the rise after intercourse is significantly greater than after masturbation; the authors take this to suggest that the former brings greater satiety.14 Prolactin is here understood as a feedback signal that inhibits renewed arousal. The sample was small and the conclusions should be regarded as preliminary. The phenomenological level. Maczkowiack and Schweitzer (2018), in an anonymous online survey of 1,208 men, found that about 41% had experienced postcoital dysphoria (unexplained sadness, agitation, or emptiness after sex) at some point in their lives, about 20% within the last four weeks, and about 4% often; the phenomenon was associated with psychological distress and sexual dysfunction.15 This shows that "post-desire emptiness" is a real and common experience, not an exaggeration of contemplative literature.
Narrowing. If the pattern of peak followed by satiety becomes the dominant mode, is it accompanied by longer-term change? Kühn and Gallinat (2014), in a study of 64 healthy men, found that weekly hours of pornography viewing were negatively correlated with the volume of the right caudate nucleus, and also negatively correlated with functional connectivity from the caudate to the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex.16 This is a cross-sectional study, and the authors themselves acknowledge that the differences observed may be a precondition of the viewing rather than its consequence; moreover, the study measured pornography consumption, not frequency of ejaculation, and did not measure dopamine receptors. Structural implication. This article does not claim that "ejaculation causes cognitive decline." It points out that the pattern of peak, satiety, and narrowing in reproductive union has correlational support at three levels: neural, endocrine, and phenomenological. This is consistent with the thesis of this article: if the generative drive is generation toward the other, then when it is narrowed into the single outlet of the reproductive system and completed in a peak-and-dissipation fashion, it will for a time lower motivation toward the mate (as Zhou et al. measured). Whether this extends to other objects, such as exploration, creation, and social life, cannot be asserted on present evidence; this article lists it only as an inference to be tested. This is not the disappearance of the generative drive but a temporary narrowing of its direction. Question left open, no. 2: Creation, compassion, and aesthetic response share one reward structure with mating; when the boundary of the self is broken and one enters union with the other, what exactly is opened? The reward structure alone cannot say.
6. Narrow and Broad: A Phenomenological Contrast The previous two sections supplied empirical correlates from natural history and neuroscience. This section contrasts, from a phenomenological angle and directly, the experiential structure of narrow-sense and broad-sense sexual experience.
6.1 The Spectrum of Pleasure "All behavior is broad-sense sexual pleasure": once this is said, the hardest question must be faced. Are mechanical, numb reactions, and aimless compulsions (such as scrolling short videos without purpose), also that? The answer of this article: yes, but in a low-sensitivity form. First, the existence of a behavior is itself evidence that some pleasure exists. If there were not even low-sensitivity pleasure, people would not perform the behavior at all. The numbness of scrolling is not "no pleasure" but a low-sensitivity state in which the reward threshold has been raised and more frequent stimulation is needed to sustain it. Second, when objects of high-order exchange are absent, or when the generative drive is blocked and cannot expand outward, compulsive discharge arises: binge eating, indulgence, even self-harm. In appearance these seem "self-destructive," but at the level of energy they are low-sensitivity pleasure: the energy, finding no high-sensitivity outlet, releases itself in the lowest-cost way. This yields a spectrum (interpretation). The high-sensitivity end is union, creation, and flow, where the generative drive expands outward and establishes connection with the world; the low-sensitivity end is dissipation, discharge, and compulsion, where the generative drive, blocked, flows back and seeks release at the lowest cost. The two ends differ in sensitivity and direction, not in presence or absence.
6.2 Informational Bandwidth The most central difference between the two kinds of experience lies in informational bandwidth. At the peak of narrow-sense sexual experience, all attention narrows to local sensation in the reproductive organs. The exchange of information between subject and world is almost entirely closed: one cannot hear sounds, cannot see light, and thought stops. This is pleasure of extremely high intensity, but the informational bandwidth falls to nearly zero. Broad-sense sexual experience is the opposite. In the state of flow, attention is highly concentrated but does not narrow: the painter sees every stroke on the canvas, the musician hears the part of every instrument in the ensemble, the mathematician follows several strands of the proof at once. The pleasure here is not an explosive peak but a lasting fullness; the informational bandwidth is not closed but reaches the upper limit of the individual's capacity. This article defines this as the information-theoretic character of broad-sense sexual experience (interpretation): it does not come at the cost of closing the world; it takes the opening of the world as its precondition. The stronger the narrow-sense experience, the narrower the world; the deeper the broad-sense experience, the wider the world.
6.3 Insight Gained The third difference lies in cognitive consequences. After narrow-sense sexual experience, beyond "this person makes me happy"
or "I need it again," a new understanding of the world seldom arises. The peak is closed: it points to itself, not elsewhere. Broad-sense sexual experience is often accompanied by insight. The creator in flow "sees" the complete form of the work; the practitioner in stillness "sees" how the mind works; the scientist in reflection "sees" the structure behind the formula. These acts of "seeing" are not metaphors: they are real cognitive reorganizations, often arising suddenly in the form of the "aha" experience. Neuroscientific research on insight shows that the "aha" moment is accompanied by a burst of gamma-band activity in the right superior temporal gyrus and by activation of the reward system (nucleus accumbens, ventral tegmental area).17 In other words, insight is both cognitive and rewarding: it brings "I understand" and "this is beautiful" at the same time. The interpretation of this article: insight is the completed form of broad-sense sexual experience in the cognitive domain. When the subject enters deep union with an object (a problem, a melody, a stretch of nature), the boundary dissolves for a time, and the understanding that emerges is not the endpoint of inference but a by-product of union. How much insight is gained depends directly on the depth of the union. Question left open, no. 3: In insight, the "seeing": is there someone who sees, or is it seeing itself?
7. The Strongest Objections
7.1 Objection One: Excessive Extension of the Concept Objection: You extend "sex" from the reproductive organs to all generation. Does this not strip the concept of its boundary and make it an all-inclusive empty phrase? Reply: The extension has a boundary. The "generative drive" of this article has a definite definition: a self-transcending drive of generation toward difference and the other. This excludes three kinds of phenomena: (1) isolated self-repetition (such as crystal growth), which is not directed toward the other; (2) passive causal transmission (such as falling dominoes), which has no self- transcendence; (3) entropy increase in a closed system (such as heat death), which produces no difference. What does not satisfy the three conditions of "toward the other," "self-transcendence," and "generating difference" falls outside the "generative drive" of this article.
7.2 Objection Two: Reductionism Objection: Are you saying that "artists create only for the sake of sex" and that "compassion is only a disguise of sexual impulse"? Does this not reduce higher spiritual activity to a lower physiological instinct? Reply: This article is not reductionist but a reconstruction in terms of genesis. Reductionism says: A (creation) is only a transformation of B (reproduction), and B is more real. This article says: A and B are manifestations of the same generative drive at different levels, and they have equal standing. Mating is no more "essential" than creation, and creation is no more "elevated" than mating; both are ways in which the generative drive moves toward the other, differing only in object and form. This does not flatten differences; it sees the sameness of structure beneath them. Just as "heat is molecular motion" does not say that "a burn is only collisions" but that the macroscopic phenomenon of heat and the microscopic motion of molecules are manifestations of one physical process at different scales.
7.3 Objection Three: The Suspicion of Teleology Objection: You say generation moves "toward" the other. Does this not presuppose a purpose? But evolution is blind and has no direction. Reply: "Toward" is not teleology but a structural description. This article does not claim that "nature intended the peacock to grow a beautiful tail." It says that under the pressure of sexual selection, the direction of variation in the tail was continuously selected by the peahen's preference, with the result that the tail was generated all along in that direction. The direction is not at the beginning; it emerges in the process. This is "toward" in the same sense as "the river flows toward the sea": not that the river has a purpose, but that terrain and gravity determine that it can only flow downhill. The generative drive moves toward the other because isolated self-repetition is eliminated under selective pressure: a life that does not move toward the other, in most cases leaves no offspring.
7.4 Objection Four: Neglect of Individual Differences Objection: Some people have very high creativity but low sexual desire, and some have strong desire but no creativity at all. How does your model explain this?
Reply: This article never claims a one-to-one correspondence between sexual desire and creativity at the level of the individual. The studies cited in Section 5 (Griskevicius et al., Nettle and Clegg) measure correlations at the group level, not determinations at the level of the individual. The thesis of this article lies one level deeper: the generative drive, as a force of generation, can be allocated to different domains, and in very different ways, in different individuals. Some people put all their generative drive into creation, and reproductive desire is hollowed out; others dissipate the generative drive in the reproductive domain, and the creative domain withers. These are not counter-examples but the rise and fall of one drive at different outlets.
8. Conclusion: Toward Part Two This article has supplied empirical correlates for "the generative drive is the world" at three levels: natural history, human behavior, and phenomenology. The peacock's tail, the orientation of the sunflower head, and canine olfaction show that a structure of generation toward the other does not depend on thought; the dandelion's pappus and the habituation of the sensitive plant show that response and sedimentation without representation also exist; neuroscientific studies of creativity, compassion, and aesthetic response show that phenomena named separately share reward circuitry; and the contrast between narrow-sense and broad-sense sexual experience shows that the two differ in informational bandwidth and object of union, not in the presence or absence of pleasure. The three levels of evidence converge in support of P3: the generative drive, that is, the self-transcending drive toward difference and the other, cannot within the domain of life be replaced by "energy," "will to power," or "reproductive instinct." It cannot be replaced by "energy," because conservation of energy cannot explain direction; it cannot be replaced by "will to power," because power may be an expansion of the self whereas the generative drive necessarily moves toward the other; and it cannot be replaced by "reproductive instinct," because reproduction is only the manifestation of the generative drive in one domain, not the whole of it. But empirical correlates cannot complete an argument for monism. P1 (the world is becoming) and P2 (becoming is toward the other) require a priori argument; C (the world is the self-differentiating modes of the generative drive) requires a final ontological leap. This is the task of Part Two, Luminous Awareness (觉知). Part One leaves questions open at three points: whether the precise coupling between structure and environment counts as "knowing"; what is opened in union with the other; and who, or what, "sees" in insight. The three questions point to one place, and Part Two will answer them. Part Two will argue that luminous awareness (juézhào 觉照, běnjué 本觉, rig pa) is not a second thing apart from the generative drive but its own luminosity (自明, self-luminosity); that manifestation and luminous awareness arise simultaneously in terms of genesis and cannot be separated; and that when awareness lingers on no object, the generative drive is released from the narrowing outlet of the narrow sense and shows itself as the source of the generation of all things. Then P1, P2, P3, and C will come together in one complete argument. (End of Part One)
Notes
1. Charles Darwin, letter to Asa Gray, 3 April 1860. Original: "The sight of a feather in a peacock's tail, whenever I gaze at it, makes me sick!"
2. Penn, D. J., & Potts, W. K. (1998). How do major histocompatibility complex genes influence odor and mating preferences? Advances in Immunology, 69, 411–
3. Horowitz, Alexandra (2009). Inside of a Dog: What Dogs See, Smell, and Know. New York: Scribner.
4. Atamian, H. S., Creux, N. M., Brown, E. A., Garner, A. G., Blackman, B. K., & Harmer, S. L. (2016). Circadian regulation of sunflower heliotropism, floral orientation, and pollinator visits. Science, 353(6299), 587–
5. Creux, N. M., et al. (2021). Flower orientation influences floral temperature, pollinator visits and plant fitness. New Phytologist. https://doi.org/10.1111/nph.17627
6. Cummins, C., et al. (2018). A separated vortex ring underlies the flight of the dandelion. Nature, 562(7727), 414–
7. Gagliano, M., et al. (2014). Experience teaches plants to learn faster and forget slower in environments where it matters. Oecologia, 175(1), 63–
8. Griskevicius, V., Cialdini, R. B., & Kenrick, D. T. (2006). Peacocks, Picasso, and parental investment: The effects of romantic motives on creativity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 91(1), 63–
9. Nettle, D., & Clegg, H. (2006). Schizotypy, creativity, and mating success in humans. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 273(1586), 611–
10. Klimecki, O. M., et al. (2014). Differential pattern of functional brain plasticity after compassion and empathy training. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 9(6), 873–
11. Miller, Geoffrey (2000). The Mating Mind: How Sexual Choice Shaped the Evolution of Human Nature. New York: Doubleday.
12. For a review, see Rhodes, G. (2006). The evolutionary psychology of facial beauty. Annual Review of Psychology, 57, 199–
13. Zhou, X., et al. (2023). Hyperexcited limbic neurons represent sexual satiety and reduce mating motivation. Science, 379(6634), 820–
14. Brody, S., & Krüger, T. H. C. (2006). The post-orgasmic prolactin increase following intercourse is greater than following masturbation and suggests greater satiety. Biological Psychology, 71(3), 312–
15. Maczkowiack, J., & Schweitzer, R. D. (2018). Postcoital dysphoria: Prevalence and correlates among males. Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy, 44(4), 1–
16. Kühn, S., & Gallinat, J. (2014). Brain structure and functional connectivity associated with pornography consumption. JAMA Psychiatry, 71(7), 827–
17. Jung-Beeman, M., et al. (2004). Neural activity when people solve verbal problems with insight. PLoS Biology, 2(4), e97; Tik, M., et al. (2018). Ultra-high-field fMRI insights on insight: Neural correlates of the Aha!-moment. Human Brain Mapping, 39, 3241–3252.
Bibliography
Classical Sources None (this part is an empirical argument and does not involve classical texts).
Modern Literature Atamian, H. S., Creux, N. M., Brown, E. A., Garner, A. G., Blackman, B. K., & Harmer, S. L. (2016). Circadian regulation of sunflower heliotropism, floral orientation, and pollinator visits. Science, 353(6299), 587–590. Brody, S., & Krüger, T. H. C. (2006). The post-orgasmic prolactin increase following intercourse is greater than following masturbation and suggests greater satiety. Biological Psychology, 71(3), 312–315. Creux, N. M., et al. (2021). Flower orientation influences floral temperature, pollinator visits and plant fitness. New Phytologist. https://doi.org/10.1111/nph.17627 Cummins, C., et al. (2018). A separated vortex ring underlies the flight of the dandelion. Nature, 562(7727), 414–418. Darwin, Charles (1871). The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex. London: John Murray. Gagliano, M., et al. (2014). Experience teaches plants to learn faster and forget slower in environments where it matters. Oecologia, 175(1), 63–72. Griskevicius, V., Cialdini, R. B., & Kenrick, D. T. (2006). Peacocks, Picasso, and parental investment: The effects of romantic motives on creativity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 91(1), 63–76. Horowitz, Alexandra (2009). Inside of a Dog: What Dogs See, Smell, and Know. New York: Scribner. Jung-Beeman, M., et al. (2004). Neural activity when people solve verbal problems with insight. PLoS Biology, 2(4), e97. Klimecki, O. M., et al. (2014). Differential pattern of functional brain plasticity after compassion and empathy training. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 9(6), 873–879. Kühn, S., & Gallinat, J. (2014). Brain structure and functional connectivity associated with pornography consumption. JAMA Psychiatry, 71(7), 827–834. Maczkowiack, J., & Schweitzer, R. D. (2018). Postcoital dysphoria: Prevalence and correlates among males. Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy, 44(4), 1–13. Miller, Geoffrey (2000). The Mating Mind: How Sexual Choice Shaped the Evolution of Human Nature. New York: Doubleday. Nettle, D., & Clegg, H. (2006). Schizotypy, creativity, and mating success in humans. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 273(1586), 611–615. Penn, D. J., & Potts, W. K. (1998). How do major histocompatibility complex genes influence odor and mating preferences? Advances in Immunology, 69, 411–436. Rhodes, G. (2006). The evolutionary psychology of facial beauty. Annual Review of Psychology, 57, 199–226. Tik, M., et al. (2018). Ultra-high-field fMRI insights on insight: Neural correlates of the Aha!-moment. Human Brain Mapping, 39, 3241–3252. Zhou, X., et al. (2023). Hyperexcited limbic neurons represent sexual satiety and reduce mating motivation. Science, 379(6634), 820–825.